TORONTO — The Toronto Maple Leafs had fallen into a troublesome employment trap.
And on Wednesday — smartly, finally — they got over the hump.
They broke a dysfunctional cycle.
In firing head coach Craig Berube on Wednesday and agreeing to pay him millions of dollars to not coach the team for the next two seasons, John Chayka and Mats Sundin did what was best for the franchise, not themselves.
Way back when a young Kyle Dubas took the GM chair, he retained the inherited Mike Babcock despite an ill fit and a slow-burn friction and a poorly kept secret that one day the job would belong to Sheldon Keefe.
When Brad Treliving took the reins from Dubas in 2023, he too stuck with the coach he was given, keeping his power dry even when a refresh felt necessary.
It’s the safe and financially prudent move. It’s also self-preservation disguised as patience.
Following the greatest year-to-year decline in Toronto’s history, a 30-point tumble from final five to bottom five, Leafs Nation was all out of patience.
So, when Chayka announced last week that “of course” he’d consider running back Berube — the coach who had overseen the defensive debacle of 2025-26 — #BerubeOut became a popular hashtag on social media.
At some point between all those closed-door meetings held with Chayka and Sundin, the new guys in charge read the room.
They made the “bigger-picture decision,” as Chayka framed it, to search for a fresh head coach — the fourth in the era of Auston Matthews, William Nylander and John Tavares.
Without question, Treliving’s flawed roster construction and the players’ uninspired performance share blame for this season’s failures, lowlighted by a minus-46 goal differential and league-high 2,633 shots allowed.
But when the 2026 Maple Leafs refused to dig in and lock down and grind away like Berube’s 2019 Blues, when the goalies’ save percentages receded to the mean, the coach failed to adapt, to work with the pieces he was given and find a way to make the sum greater than the parts.
“We’re trying to play a certain way here, and I don’t think that we fully grabbed that buy-in that way,” Berube said, minutes after coaching his final game for the Leafs, a seventh straight loss. “We tried to do a lot of different things this year, and it didn’t work out.”
It didn’t work out for Morgan Rielly, dashing through the show. Or Matthews, stuffed too frequently in the defensive zone and missing a true get-him-the-puck wingman. Or Scott Laughton, whose importance instantly jumped after a trade to L.A.
Or Berube himself, whose frustration rarely but pointedly boiled over as his message was repeatedly returned to sender.
There was the pointed “ask those guys, not me” dagger during a lifeless stretch in December. The suggestion by Berube that he couldn’t give his players heart as rival Ottawa zipped by Toronto in the standings. And his repeated diagnosis that the Leafs have “a mental block” when it comes to rising to the moment.
Successful teams can have a chicken-or-egg debate over which comes first, the good vibes or the winning. What is not up for debate is that the 2025-26 Maple Leafs had neither.
Only time will tell how much of a difference swapping out Berube — a standup man who loves to coach more than, evidently, this group loves playing for him — will make for these Leafs.
The GM and coach both got the axe, punishment for the first missed post-season in a decade. Two layers of excuses have been removed from the core. More losing, and the next major change should come at the player level.
With Chayka and Sundin’s goal being to spin momentum and, at a bare minimum, make life inside and outside the Maple Leafs feel different, revitalized, the charts and hearts agree: This was the only move.
Even if, for Chayka, Berube Out was not the safest way out.
That, in itself, is an encouraging sign for a regime hired under a cloud of skepticism.
The window may be smaller, but they’re thinking bigger.
1:45
3:19